USA Elections

Off Topic Comments Area

Moderators: Balthagor, Legend, Moderators

Post Reply

Vote!

Democratic Party
10
27%
Republican Party
11
30%
Green Party
4
11%
Libertarian Party
3
8%
Prohibition Party
0
No votes
Socialist Party USA
3
8%
Independent
5
14%
Other
1
3%
 
Total votes: 37
Hullu Hevonen
General
Posts: 3604
Joined: Dec 11 2008
Location: Turunmaa/Turunseutu, Suomi
Contact:

Re: USA Elections

Post by Hullu Hevonen »

tkobo wrote:Its only that way in the US because the socialists havent completed their soft sell job yet.It could easily end up just like other parts of the world,were violence is the socialists way to steal for themselves what their governments didnt for them.And of course their governments way to steal to begin with,setting the example.

If they ever manage to convince enough of the population here in the US that sitting back and taking from others is better then producing,the killing fields socialism creates will form here also.
--
The problem is as simple as can be.

When people are told they are entitled to the products of others work,and they fall for it,they begin to "see" they no longer need to work themselves.It then becomes "okay" for them to work less,or even not at all,in their mind. Well, socialism isn't exactly that, socialism bases its distrubition on the principle of work, so if you don't work you get less. While communism would be more correct in that eg. since they distrubute equally, no mather what. :-)

This means theres less to go around.Less people bothering to produce,and even less production from those. True for communism, kinda fuzzy for Socialism.

And as people see their work efforts being taken from them,they lose even more incentive to work.Lessening production even more
Where did their work go? HUH
This means theres even less to go around.And now even more who want it.

As the product supplies dwindles,those who believe they are entitled to it decide its fine for them to take it themselves .The government isnt giving them what it told them they were entitled to,and so they must now themselves take for themselves what their government has failed to take for them. I have fallen of the track :-(

Those who are have some,now become the target of those who want.The government says they are both entitled to it,and both now feel justified in taking from each other.Without a rational theme of "you get what you earn",both now have nothing to guide them in deciding what and how much they should have,and how they should get it,other than the claim that they are entitled to it.

It called conflict.You now have competing members of the population all told they are entitled to things,that there isnt enough of to go around.AND people who have been told thats it okay for the government to take things from others via force,to give to them.And hence its okay for them to do the same.

And it becomes okay to steal that loaf of bread,even when those its stolen from needed it just as much,because the story is told of how "they were entitled to the bread as much as the other guy,and society is responsible in the end for not supplying the bread to all.The thief was just doing what it had to,its not his fault ".I have no idea what your talking about in this middle section and what it has to do with "Socialism". Care to explain? :-) Ou, please explain in a manner clearer then this one, I am not familiar with method of explaining. It currently makes no sense to me. I wan't to understand so we may avoid misunderstandings and flaming wars.

Welcome to socialism.Welcome to the killing fields.Well, I don't know how much socialists have killed, but Communists where they who where the most agressive and dangerous.

Just put a handful of junkies in need of their fix,in a locked room with only enough of their chosen drug for one.Its the same dynamic.Keep them there,and each day only put enough of the drug into the room for one......what does a junkie have to do with this kind of politics. Capitalism, Anarchism, Nationalism etc have Junkies too??? Don't US have a big drug problem, they ain't socialist.

Violence will be the end result,its just a matter of how long til its reached.

And all it takes is for the lessening of production and available product that socialism promotes,to move production lower than the consumption it also promotes.
I don't know what your point is and if it is fact based. I got the impression that there where alot of killing and junkies and other stuff, I get the feeling that your throwing a bunch of negatives without any reference to actual facts. Also, I hope your not generalising the term socialist to include other ideologies. Most of what I understood of what you said would apply to communists in former Warsaw pact, DPRK and China. Though China has takes some steps away from othodox communism today. I don't mean to be mean, I only don't understand your post and would, if you care, to get a better explanation(atleast I wan't one, don't know about others). I'm trying my self to type as good as English I can, to decrease the chance of getting miss understood.
Here's some reading for you, if you mix ideologies
http://www.socialismvscommunism.org/
http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-the-dif ... munism.htm
Happy Linux user!
Links: List of Mods
User avatar
fool
General
Posts: 1364
Joined: Mar 28 2009

Re: USA Elections

Post by fool »

Another rant attacking a strawman. Hooray.
"All warfare is based on deception...
Hold out baits to entice the enemy. Feign disorder, and crush him."

Sun Tzu, The Art of War
User avatar
Lightbringer
General
Posts: 2973
Joined: May 23 2006
Location: Texas

Re: USA Elections

Post by Lightbringer »

@Fool,

Really? Tkobo's post may have been a bit hyperbolic, but the underlying decay of Human spirit seems pretty real to me. Let's use an example you may have noticed... How many people are on the Dole in Britain? And yet, how many millions of immigrants did y'all let in to do factory work and the like? A generation or two later... how many kids and grandkids of those immigrants are on the Dole? Rinse and repeat across Europe.

@Hullu,

He didn't say the work was gone... he said the worker's desire to work had been replaced by free crap from Big Brother. And I'm not trying to flame socialism, but he has a point. A certain, sadly large, percentage of humanity will live off of less if they do not have to work for it. Especially if some Politician keeps telling them they deserve more and more every election. The Democrats in the U.S. have been taking advantage of this Fact for a century, and with each successive generation, they spread the notion further and further through the population.

-Light
"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.” -Winston Churchill
User avatar
fool
General
Posts: 1364
Joined: Mar 28 2009

Re: USA Elections

Post by fool »

I don't see the relevance really, but why does unemployment mean I should accept that governments should be able to tell me where I can or cannot live? If that's what you were implying. Or is it that everyone who's unemployed is too lazy to git a jerb?
"All warfare is based on deception...
Hold out baits to entice the enemy. Feign disorder, and crush him."

Sun Tzu, The Art of War
The Khan
General
Posts: 1839
Joined: Nov 06 2007

Re: USA Elections

Post by The Khan »

fool wrote: who's unemployed is too lazy to git a jerb?
:lol:
I cant play SR2020 well but I still love 2010. Chris will hate me for exploiting his game to death.
Date of Order: 2007-11-15 20:03
Product information:
Supreme Ruler 2010 (1 x 19.99 USD)
3 years baby
User avatar
tkobo
Supreme Ruler
Posts: 12397
Joined: Jun 04 2002
Location: In a vast zionist plot ...RIGHT BEHIND YOU ! Oh Noes !

Re: USA Elections

Post by tkobo »

Its like in the softsell,where they will try and say "but that was communism,not socialism",trying to hide the fact that Communism IS a form of socialism.Same as stalinism,marxism,green anarchism,ba'athism,national socialism,etc.. all are.

They'll purposefully fail to connect the various russian purges of old,the cambodian killing fields,the cuban purges,the north korean purges,the purges under ba'athism,etc....to socialism.And watch the emotional denial when you show the national socialism purges used the planks of socialism.

Watch the denial when you point out all the violent socialist protests,be it in england,greece,etc....Or all the violent socialist terror groups.

Or how "leading" socialists promote the creation of "crisis" as the way to gain power.
This post approved by Tkobo:Official Rabble Rouser of the United Yahoos
Chuckle TM
Hullu Hevonen
General
Posts: 3604
Joined: Dec 11 2008
Location: Turunmaa/Turunseutu, Suomi
Contact:

Re: USA Elections

Post by Hullu Hevonen »

Lightbringer wrote:@Fool,

Really? Tkobo's post may have been a bit hyperbolic, but the underlying decay of Human spirit seems pretty real to me. Let's use an example you may have noticed... How many people are on the Dole in Britain? And yet, how many millions of immigrants did y'all let in to do factory work and the like? A generation or two later... how many kids and grandkids of those immigrants are on the Dole? Rinse and repeat across Europe.

@Hullu,

He didn't say the work was gone... he said the worker's desire to work had been replaced by free crap from Big Brother. And I'm not trying to flame socialism, but he has a point. A certain, sadly large, percentage of humanity will live off of less if they do not have to work for it. Especially if some Politician keeps telling them they deserve more and more every election. The Democrats in the U.S. have been taking advantage of this Fact for a century, and with each successive generation, they spread the notion further and further through the population.

-Light
The laziness factor is true when talking about communism, but socialist give you less if you work less.

Well, Here in Finland, if you want to, you can stay home and get 'funds'('Social security') from the government and live like that, though only a miniority of the unemployed do this. The funds you get are merely enough to pay for a rat-holes rent and some food (so many people don't do that). And if you want it little better, you can go apply for a apprenticeship job, through Kansaneläkelaitos, they offer to pay for your work for 6-12 months(if i remember correctly), you work at a job, the job pays nothing for you, instead KELA(Kansaneläkelaitos) pays you a measly sum of money, this is often a useful way for the employer to see if he should higher this worker or not and this is better for the worker as well as he gets slightly more money and gets to do something during the day. So after 6months the formerly unemployed might get himself employed there and get a real salary(the places that take these workers and higher later are often not high paid jobs). Even if you don't get employed, you have atleast got a new job merit that will help you in the future. The Gov also helps you find jobs by upkeeping a website with a huge number of open jobs, they provide a person that helps you make a CV, find open jobs, tells you how to seek a job properly etc. So with a willing gov this can be very effective. I was once unemployed, it took me less than one month with their help to find myself work. Everyone is not so lucky.

But, most people don't want to get into this system in the first place and tries to find a new job right away, besides you getting little money(that pays the rent and gives you food), many view as being unemployed as embarrassing, plus most oftenly people want to work. And so far Finland is considered a social-ish/social democratic country.
Happy Linux user!
Links: List of Mods
The Khan
General
Posts: 1839
Joined: Nov 06 2007

Re: USA Elections

Post by The Khan »

But, most people don't want to get into this system in the first place and tries to find a new job right away, besides you getting little money(that pays the rent and gives you food), many view as being unemployed as embarrassing, plus most oftenly people want to work. And so far Finland is considered a social-ish/social democratic country.
that is the point. HOW DO YOU MAKE THE REST OF THE WORLD LIKE THIS

also Light, consider that these people do want to work in a socialist government, so theres got to be more to the action that makes people work.
I cant play SR2020 well but I still love 2010. Chris will hate me for exploiting his game to death.
Date of Order: 2007-11-15 20:03
Product information:
Supreme Ruler 2010 (1 x 19.99 USD)
3 years baby
Hullu Hevonen
General
Posts: 3604
Joined: Dec 11 2008
Location: Turunmaa/Turunseutu, Suomi
Contact:

Re: USA Elections

Post by Hullu Hevonen »

@Tkobo
I understand you, but I do not agree :wink: . Communism is a violent branch of Socialism, National Socialism is based on Nationalism who took socialistic ideas and incorporated it into it. And what does green-anarchism have to do with anything?
capitalism did also support violence in countries like, countries like Cuba, Vietnamn, Nicaragua, dominican republic, Israel(still continuing today), anti-communist purge of Indonesia, Afghanistan etc. so please before blaming all evil on socialism, take a look at the other side as well. well this goes [_]OT . So to conclude the Socialism debate here in this thread about US elections, Do you think social democracy is the same as Commusim/socialism?

@Khan
How do the rest of the world become like this? well listen to them who what to change it to this and don't be so fobic about it etc. Just because one or two things are socialistic, doesn't mean they are bad and the people who proposed them are after you. Why can't you have the benifits from Capitalism and socialism? If you have a capitalist implementing socialism, well then it's gona fail, he will take the increased taxes and put it in his own pocket, say he has implemented universal health care(that propably will be steard by companies(that want profit), not the state) etc . It will have to be a team effort and not only from capitalists or socialist. You can't force someone to become something he dosen't wan't.

One reason why people want to work is because the amount of money you get is barley enough to basic needs. A social democratic society does not leave anyone to die on the streets(unless that person wants so), but if you are willing to work, you will get a salery and get more economic freedom. Many this are the same for rich and poor, for eg. health care, education, social assistance etc. So a rich person sits on the same bench with the same rights and opportunities as the poor. If a kid has difficulties in school he gets help no mather his background. While in the private life, you are free to do what you please, so if your rich, well nice for you. If a rich or poor man wants to start a company he may apply for a 650€/6-24months/monthly(if I remember correctly) state subsidy, So in a good case, the rich man becomes no poorer and the poor man gets a self-sufficient company when the subsidy ends, in a bad case the both loose.

You are free to do whatever you wan't with your money, buy a new car, live in a fancy house, etc. anyone can sell stuff freely on markets, start almost what ever companies they please, move where ever they please, belong to what ever organization they please etc.

Well all of this starts to go [_]OT
Happy Linux user!
Links: List of Mods
User avatar
fool
General
Posts: 1364
Joined: Mar 28 2009

Re: USA Elections

Post by fool »

that is the point. HOW DO YOU MAKE THE REST OF THE WORLD LIKE THIS

also Light, consider that these people do want to work in a socialist government, so theres got to be more to the action that makes people work.
Bear in mind social democracy is not socialism.

Speaking of which, maybe this'd clear things up. Bear in mind things listed under 'compatible' may not be necessary in order to be called socialism, it's strictly things that don't by their own existence make something cease to be socialism.

Is combatible with socialism:
Society as a whole deciding where the produce of each individual ends up
Control of the economy and thus everyone's working lives by a democratic state
Taxes issued by a democratic state
Complete equality of access to goods and services organised by society as a whole or a democratic state
Lack of a state
Distribution of goods and services by means of the free market
Control of workplaces by workers
Control of workplaces by society as whole
Lack of any taxes whatsoever
Currency
Lack of currency
Some people earning more per time than others
Everyone earning the same per time
Everyone earning the same regardless of time
Killing old people for lulz
The Borg (probably, I can't say I'm a star trek fan so I'm not entirely sure)



Is not compatible with socialism:
Profit, interest and rent (the real biggie, most of the other examples derive from this one)
Banks lending with interest
An unelected tyrant stealing everyone's moniez
Any business owned by an individual employing more than his/herself
Crumpets
Taxes issued by a body not under democratic control
Private ownership of land
Any situation where a worker has zero (as distinct from negligible, which would be found in the 'controlled by a democratic state' situation) control over their workplace
Michael Moore's investments
Leaders
Liberalism, in the classical and the current American sense of the word
"All warfare is based on deception...
Hold out baits to entice the enemy. Feign disorder, and crush him."

Sun Tzu, The Art of War
User avatar
Lightbringer
General
Posts: 2973
Joined: May 23 2006
Location: Texas

Re: USA Elections

Post by Lightbringer »

@Fool,

My point was that at the same exact time frame you had millions on the Dole, you also had millions of immigrants. Now either they went to work at factories for low wages, or they went straight onto the dole. Either way, the Dole system is causing a disconnect between people and working for a living. As for your protestations that because your system isn't 100% pure socialism then it isn't socialism at all? Let me phrase it another way. The SOCIALISTIC COMPONENTS of your society are eroding the non socialistic components. Basically like a leech that never stops growing as long as you keep feeding it. Well Western Europe now each has a 40 Kilo leech on their backs. The U.S. has a President that is feeding growth hormones to our leech, at the same time that the rest of the world is experimenting with sprinkling salt on theirs. Greece et al. are stumbling and at death's door from the amount of blood their leeches are sucking out of them. If the United States does not become suddenly serious about reversing the trend, we will fall as well.

@Hullu,

Good for y'all having some common sense.

-Light
"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.” -Winston Churchill
Hullu Hevonen
General
Posts: 3604
Joined: Dec 11 2008
Location: Turunmaa/Turunseutu, Suomi
Contact:

Re: USA Elections

Post by Hullu Hevonen »

fool wrote:
that is the point. HOW DO YOU MAKE THE REST OF THE WORLD LIKE THIS

also Light, consider that these people do want to work in a socialist government, so theres got to be more to the action that makes people work.
Bear in mind social democracy is not socialism.

Speaking of which, maybe this'd clear things up. Bear in mind things listed under 'compatible' may not be necessary in order to be called socialism, it's strictly things that don't by their own existence make something cease to be socialism.

Is combatible with socialism:
Society as a whole deciding where the produce of each individual ends up
Control of the economy and thus everyone's working lives by a democratic state
Taxes issued by a democratic state
Complete equality of access to goods and services organised by society as a whole or a democratic state
Lack of a state
Distribution of goods and services by means of the free market
Control of workplaces by workers
Control of workplaces by society as whole
Lack of any taxes whatsoever
Currency
Lack of currency
Some people earning more per time than others
Everyone earning the same per time
Everyone earning the same regardless of time
Killing old people for lulz
The Borg (probably, I can't say I'm a star trek fan so I'm not entirely sure)



Is not compatible with socialism:
Profit, interest and rent (the real biggie, most of the other examples derive from this one)
Banks lending with interest
An unelected tyrant stealing everyone's moniez
Any business owned by an individual employing more than his/herself
Crumpets
Taxes issued by a body not under democratic control
Private ownership of land
Any situation where a worker has zero (as distinct from negligible, which would be found in the 'controlled by a democratic state' situation) control over their workplace
Michael Moore's investments
Leaders
Liberalism, in the classical and the current American sense of the word
I ain't sure I agree whit all those or how correct they are, "Killing old people for lulz", well Social democrats don't kill people, but I don't care to discus Social Democracy/Socialism any further :)
Happy Linux user!
Links: List of Mods
User avatar
Lightbringer
General
Posts: 2973
Joined: May 23 2006
Location: Texas

Re: USA Elections

Post by Lightbringer »

"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.” -Winston Churchill
The Khan
General
Posts: 1839
Joined: Nov 06 2007

Re: USA Elections

Post by The Khan »

what about the debt ceiling? they still fight.
I cant play SR2020 well but I still love 2010. Chris will hate me for exploiting his game to death.
Date of Order: 2007-11-15 20:03
Product information:
Supreme Ruler 2010 (1 x 19.99 USD)
3 years baby
Hullu Hevonen
General
Posts: 3604
Joined: Dec 11 2008
Location: Turunmaa/Turunseutu, Suomi
Contact:

Re: USA Elections

Post by Hullu Hevonen »

Happy Linux user!
Links: List of Mods
Post Reply

Return to “Off Topic Comments”